Deliciously Decadent Mini Butterfingers Cookie Cake

Jump Pin Save
40 minutes

This post may contain affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

This shop has been compensated by Collective Bias, Inc. and its advertiser. All opinions are mine alone. #mixinmoments #CollectiveBias

Looking for a delicious dessert that won’t take all day to make? This mouthwatering mini Butterfingers Cookie Cake is exactly what you need. What could be better than the peanut buttery taste of Butterfingers combined with a delicious chocolate chip cookie? It’s a match made in heaven!

I seriously love that this mini cookie cake combines the peanut butter taste of Butterfingers combined with a delicious chocolate chip cookie! This Butterfingers Cookie Cake is a match made in heaven! #mixinmoments #ad

I seriously love baking!  When I was a little girl spending summer vacations with my grandma, we’d sometimes spend an entire day in the kitchen baking cookies, English muffins and lots of other yummy treats from scratch.  Even though that was a few years ago, I still enjoy baking just as much as I always have.  However, these days it’s very rare that I would have hours on end to spend in the kitchen like in the “good ‘ol days”.

That’s why I was excited to discover these new premium Nestle Toll House Baking Mixes  because you can make amazing recipes in a short amount amount of time. These mixes can be used as is to make delicious cookies and brownies but if you want to get a little fancy, you can put your own twist on it.  These baking mixes are so versatile that the possibilities are endless.  Let everyone think you spent all day in the kitchen when you really just used Nestle Toll House Baking Mixes…no one ever has to know!

There are four mouthwatering flavors to choose from: Brownies & More With Butterfingers, Brownies & More With Chocolate Morsels, Cookies & More With Butterfingers and Cookies & More With Chocolate Morsels. Plus, they have no artificial flavors or colors so I can feel good about giving them to my family.

Since my hubby loves both Butterfingers and chocolate chip cookies, this was recipe was a no brainer!  I knew he’d love the mini Butterfingers Cookie Cake I had in mind so I headed out to Walmart to pick up what I needed.  The recipe is actually so easy that I only had to buy three ingredients…Nestle Toll House baking mix (Cookies & More With Butterfingers), Nestle Toll House Milk Chocolate Chips and a bag of fun size Butterfingers bars.


I also picked up some of the other flavors to try out later.  Brownies are a little too chocolate-y for my hubby but they are right up my alley…I’m a firm believer that there’s no such thing as too much chocolate!!!  These mixes are also perfect to keep on hand for when you need to whip up a last minute treat for a party or have friends coming over.


I’d found these mini cake pans on sale a few weeks ago and have been dying to try them out!  I knew they’d be perfect for my recipe!


Now it was time to get to work.  I love that there aren’t many steps involved…easy recipes are my favorite and you can’t get much easier than three steps and three ingredients!  I started by preparing the mix using the directions on the box.  Look at all these yummy chunks of Butterfingers and chocolate!


I filled the four mini pans (be sure to use non-stick cooking spray first), then baked at 350° for about 18 minutes.  Once they were finished cooking, I let them cool completely and removed them from the pans.  They looked and smelled so good that I wanted to take a big bite right then…somehow I managed to control myself!


The opening in the middle was just the right size for some chopped Butterfinger pieces.


Finally it was time to drizzle the chocolate and sprinkle a few Butterfinger crumbles over the top.  It’s really not even fair how easy this was!


5 from 12 votes

Deliciously Decadent Butterfingers Cookie Cake

Author Lisa O'Driscoll | Fun Money Mom
Cuisine American
Prep Time 20 minutes
Cook Time 20 minutes
Total Time 40 minutes
This super easy, 3 ingredient Butterfingers Cookie Cake will have everyone thinking you spent all day in the kitchen!


  • NESTLÉ® TOLL HOUSE® Cookies & More Cookie Baking Mix with Butterfingers
  • 8-10 Butterfingers fun size bars
  • 3/4 cup NESTLÉ® TOLL HOUSE® Milk Chocolate Morsels


  • Prepare the baking mix according to directions on box
  • Fill four mini baking pans with the cookie dough
  • Bake 18-20 minutes, then allow to cool
  • Chop Butterfingers into about 6-8 pieces per bar
  • When you're chopping the Butterfingers, there will be a lot of little crumbles left over. Save those to sprinkle over the finished cake.
  • Fill the middle of the cookie cakes with chopped Butterfinger pieces
  • Melt the milk chocolate morsels and drizzle over the top
  • Sprinkle with Butterfinger crumbles and serve.


Calories: 720kcal | Carbohydrates: 110g | Protein: 8g | Saturated Fat: 16g | Cholesterol: 5mg | Sodium: 298mg | Fiber: 3g | Sugar: 76g
The nutrition information provided is an estimate and can vary based on cooking methods and ingredients used.

Did You Make This Recipe?

Share it with me on Instagram @funmoneymom and follow on Pinterest @funmoneymom for more!

I couldn’t take it anymore and I finally had to have a taste…it was delicious!  These Nestle Toll House Baking Mixes are the way to go!

Let’s be friends!

Did you love this post? Make sure to comment below and let me know your thoughts! And don’t forget to follow on your favorite social network below!

Fun in your inbox

Get the latest recipes, crafts and more straight to your inbox

Notify of

Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

5 stars
oh WOW. This looks amazing. I really need to try this recipe! Yummy.

What a clever use of that pan! I need to try this cookie mix ASAP!

5 stars
You have the coolest baking stuff. I am not a fan of baking, but I can handle boxed stuff. You inspire me to bake more!

I’m going to be on the lookout for some pans like those. You make such awesome creations with things like that! And the chocolate on this looks amazing. No such thing as too much chocolate! (My hubby is like yours, though. More chocolate for us, right?)

Where did you purchase the pans?

I haven’t seen these baking mixes, but they definitely look delicious. Add your additions and your cakes look decadent! And those cute little pans; where did you find them?

Oh my goodness, this looks heavenly. I’d eat all four at once! 😉

What an easy delicious looking recipe! Love the added chocolate drizzle (and you’re right – there is never too much chocolate!) I’ve got to find those pans too – sooo cute!

Those Butterfingers Cookie Cake look amazing!! I am glad you enjoyed the new NESTLÉ® TOLL HOUSE® baking mixes. Thanks #client

This looks delicious… my daughter just asked if she can make it. LOL! I think we’ll need some new cake pans!

I’m not creative enough to think of doing a variation like this. Would make a pretty tray of goodies for a party.

Wow, these cookie cakes look super decadent! I love the personal-sized pans you used, too.

Decadent is definitely the perfect word for this! Yum! I’d love for you to stop by and link up with us at Friday Favorites.

5 stars
You make the butterfingers cookie cakes look and sound so very delicious. The cake pans are perfect with the opening to add more goodies.

Bloggers Pit Stop

Never heard of these mixes before. Will surely be looking for them. Thanks for getting out the word about them.

5 stars
If Walmart doesn’t have the cake pans I’ll bet that Bed,Bath/and Beyond would. Seriously they have an interesting collection of cookware.

Similar Posts