41 Magical Harry Potter Recipes

Harry Potter recipes are perfect for more than just your Harry Potter party! Whip up a mug of butterbeer for your movie night or even a treacle tart for game night! No matter what the occasion, this delicious Harry Potter food will make it that much better!

For your convenience, this post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

This list was originally posted in January 2018 but I continue to update it as I come across fun new recipes to share!

If you’re having a Harry Potter party, you’re going to need a lot of stuff! You’ll want Harry Potter invitations, thank you cards and especially cool activities like this DIY Harry Potter wand!

Harry Potter Recipes

Of course, you’ll want plenty of Harry Potter food too!  From frothy butterbeer to  Harry Potter cakes, there are enough Harry Potter-inspired treats here for a gazillion parties or movie nights.

These are just a few of our favorites but keep reading to get the entire list…

• Butterbeer
• Boozy Butterbeer
• Butterbeer Jell-o Shots
• Polyjuice Potion Punch
• Pumpkin Juice
• Golden Snitch Cake
• Monster Book Of Monsters Cake
• Sorting Hat Cupcakes
• Cauldron Cakes
• Pumpkin Pasties
• Treacle Tart
• Elves Curry Puffs
• Howler Pastries
• Cockroach Clusters
• Golden Snitch Truffles
• Deathly Hallows Sugar Cookies
• Acid Pops
• Pretzel Wands
• Lemondrop Candies
• Sorting Hat Cookies
• Chocolate Frogs
• Monster Book Snacks
• Harry Potter Hot Cocoa Bombs

Most of these recipes are easy, like chocolate frogs made from a simple candy frog mold. Others, like the Golden Snitch Cake will take a little more work. I did this on a smaller scale recently with these Golden Snitch Peanut Butter Balls…so fun to make and super delish too!

The hardest part might just be picking a favorite but if you need even more recipe ideas, check out this Harry Potter Recipes Book) 

Butterbeer Recipes

Harry Potter Butterbeer

When we visited The Wizarding World Of Harry Potter in Universal Studios, finding butterbeer was at the top of our list! It was so delish that when we got home, we wanted to recreate the recipe on our own.

Not only was this butterbeer recipe super easy to recreate, it tastes just like the real thing. With just four ingredients and a couple of minutes, you can whip up a batch of your own. You’ll feel like you’ve been transported straight to Diagon Alley!

Hot Butterbeer

Too chilly outside for a cold drink? Skip the hot chocolate and make this hot butterbeer instead! I love this option for Halloween parties too!

Marshmallow Butterbeer Latte

While hot butterbeer sounds good, I’ll be making this marshmallow butterbeer latte next time the temperatures drop. This expresso drink, sweetened with brown sugar and topped with whipped cream and marshmallows, totally has me drooling!

Boozy Butterbeer

For the grownups only: While the kids are enjoying the regular Harry Potter food and drinks, grownups can take it up a notch with Boozy Butterbeer instead!

Butterbeer Jell-o Shots

While you’re making boozy versions, you definitely don’t want to leave out these awesome Butterbeer Jell-o Shots! This is such a fun recipe that I may even hand these out to the grownup trick-or-treaters at Halloween!

Butterbeer Food Recipes

Butterbeer Cookie Mugs

You’ll need something to eat with your butterbeer and these Butterbeer Cookie Mugs from Hungry Happenings look pretty tasty!

Butterbeer Pudding Cookies

Just like there’s more than one kind of butterbeer, there are plenty of butterbeer cookie recipes to go around too. Butterbeer Pudding Cookies from Sugar Bean Bakers would be perfect for your party.

Butterbeer Muddy Buddies

Take traditional muddy buddies to the next level with Butterbeer Muddy Buddies instead. I may even whip up a batch and give them as gifts to all my Harry Potter loving friends.

Butterbeer Ice Cream

There aren’t many delicious treats we love more than ice cream, which is why this Butterbeer Ice Cream recipe is so perfect for a party! The bonus is that since it’s no churn, this recipe is pretty simple to make too.

Butterbeer Pancakes

If you want an entire day filled with delicious treats, why not start it off with some Butterbeer Pancakes! It would make a fun breakfast surprise for your birthday boy or girl. Plus, who wouldn’t want to wake up to find these on the breakfast table!

Harry Potter Drink Recipes (that aren’t butterbeer)

Polyjuice Potion

Whip up a batch of this Polyjuice Potion Punch, then sit back and watch your guests turn into other people! Okay, we know that the stuff in the Harry Potter movies doesn’t actually happen in real life…but it sure would be cool!

Pumpkin Juice (With Apple Juice)

When the students sat down for meals at the Great Hall, they didn’t drink butterbeer…they drank pumpkin juice. In the wizarding world, it’s the equivalent of orange juice.

That’s why this Copycat Pumpkin Juice Recipe makes another great drink option for your party. You’ll just need pumpkin puree, pumpkin pie spice and a few other ingredients to make a batch of your own.

Harry Potter Cakes And Cupcakes

Harry Potter Always Cake

When my daughter first asked me to recreate this Harry Potter Cake from Pinterest, I had my doubts. Clearly that one was made by a professional and I wasn’t sure I’d pull it off.

Though it wasn’t quite as extravagant as the original, we were pretty happy with the results. My daughter absolutely loved her cake and in the end, that’s all that matters!

Golden Snitch Cake

Now, if you want to talk about professional cakes, check out this Harry Potter Golden Snitch Cake. Your guests will be amazed when they see this awesome creation!

Harry Potter Unicorn Cake

Cauldron Cakes

These Harry Potter Cauldron Cakes don’t look like any cupcakes we’ve seen before! Made with chocolate cake and filled with a homemade marshmallow filling, it’s the perfect treat for your dessert table.

Hedwig Inspired Owl Cupcakes

These owl cupcakes are super easy to make and the perfect dessert if you’re running short on time!

Sorting Hat Cupcakes

Let the kids pick one of these Sorting Hat Cupcakes for a fun surprise. Each one contains a different color so they’ll have to take a bite to find out which Hogwart’s House they belong in.

 Harry Potter Pasties And Pies

Pumpkin Pasties

If you want Harry Potter savory recipes, you’ve got to try these yummy looking Harry Potter Pumpkin Pasties. In the world of Harry Potter, pumpkin pasties are said to be similar to a cornish pastry, but filled with pumpkin instead.

They’re normally found on the Hogwarts Express but now you can serve up a batch of your own.

Elves Curry Puffs

If they’re good enough for the elves, these savory Elves Curry Puffs are good enough for us too.

Traditional Treacle Tart

If you’ve read the Harry Potter books, you already know that the Treacle Tart is Harry’s favorite dessert! The best part about this one is that it’s so simple to make, you probably already have the ingredients in your pantry.

Treacle Tart With Rosemary & Lemon

This treacle tart version looks just as delish! I love the combination of ingredients like brown butter, rosemary and lemon and can’t wait to give this one a try.

Harry Potter Howlers

Normally nobody wants to see one of these show up! However these edible version of Harry Potter Howlers are a lot more fun than the movie ones.

More Harry Potter Food

Broomsticks

How cute are these Cheese And Pretzel Broomsticks? Not only are they easy to make but they also give kids a healthier alternative to choose from.

Cockroach Clusters

Think you could eat a cockroach? How about if it were made with chocolate and pecans? Kids will love being grossed out by these buggy Cockroach Clusters.

Spellbook Treats

You’ll never guess what’s inside these adorable spellbook treats. I don’t want to ruin the surprise but let’s just say that that your guests are going to love these surprisingly simple, and delicious, snacks!

Golden Snitch Truffles

You’ll have to be fast to get one of these golden snitch truffles before they all fly off the plate. Made with OREO cookies, they’re sure to disappear fast.

Deathly Hallows Sugar Cookies

If you’re looking for easy Harry Potter cookies, try these Deathly Hallows Sugar Cookies. You can never go wrong with cookies and these fit the theme perfectly.

Acid Pops

Sold at Honeydukes Sweetshop, acid pops are similar to lollipops but with an unusual twist. They burn a hole in your tongue (which Ron Weasley learned the hard way).

Luckily, muggles like us have nothing to worry about. This fun treat is a much safer version.

Ferrero Rocher Golden Snitches

Not only do these Golden Snitches fit perfectly with the Harry Potter theme, they’re super easy to make too. Just add these printable wings to Ferrero Rocher candies and you’ve got a simple to make treat that tastes delish!

Butterbeer Fudge

With so much flavor in one little bite, everyone will want a second (or maybe a third) piece of this delicious butterbeer fudge!

Harry Potter Pretzel Wands

I’m a huge fan of giving treat bags with food instead of trinkets. The kids always love getting treats to bring home and moms love not having extra toys lying around.

Make these Harry Potter Pretzel Wands and put them in a bag tied with pretty ribbon for the perfect goodie bag idea.

Butterbeer Popcorn

If you’re having a Harry Potter movie night, there’s nothing more perfect than a big bowl of butterbeer popcorn! You can never go wrong with a combination of sweet and salty!

Lemon Drop Candies

Dumbledore loved his lemon drops! These Lemon Drop Candies are the perfect mix of sweet and sour and I totally get why it was Dumbledore’s favorite muggle candy.

Sorting Hat Cookies

What house would the sorting hat put you in? Find out with these fun sorting hat cookies. It’s such a clever idea and the kids will have a blast finding out which house they’ve been assigned to!

Harry Potter Chocolate Frogs

Wizards get hungry when their riding the Hogwarts Express and if they’re quick enough, they may just catch one of these chocolate frogs. We made these our own Harry Potter party and they were a big hit…and they didn’t even try to get away!

Monster Book Snacks

One of the most recognizable characters in the movies has to be the Monster Book Of Monsters. That’s why I’m loving these Monster Book Snacks!

This would also be a fun party activity. Just set out the ingredients and the kids would have a blast making their own monster.

Butterbeer Sandwich Cookies

These Butterbeer Sandwich Cookies remind me a lot of whoopie pies…but with a tasty butterbeer twist.

Harry Potter Hot Chocolate Bombs

I am seriously loving these Harry Potter Hot Cocoa Bombs! They’re so cute and original that it’s almost a shame to ruin them with hot milk…but we’re going to do it anyway!

Which of these Harry Potter recipes will you try first? I think the Harry Potter Howlers would be fun to make and of course I’d have to try the Butterbeer! What Harry Potter food should I add to the list?

More Harry Potter Ideas